Websites
December 4, 2024

5 Small Business Website Goals: How to Define Success and Drive Growth

Zach Sean

Whenever I start working with a new client, the first question I always ask is: "What does success look like for you?"


It's a simple question, but an important one. The answers I get are surprisingly diverse.


Some business owners want more leads and sales. Others prioritize brand awareness and social proof. Many just want a "nice looking" website - though they can rarely articulate what that means!


In this post, I'll break down the 5 main goals most small business owners have for their websites and online marketing efforts.

Goal #1: Get More Leads and Sales

For many businesses, the #1 goal is increasing leads and customers.


This often comes from a fear of "we need more leads or we'll go out of business!"


While important, this mindset can be dangerous if taken too far. Just focusing on lead gen tactics without an overarching strategy leads to:

  • Wasted ad spend chasing every new shiny object
  • Mismatched messaging that confuses ideal customers
  • Technical issues that drive away customers

The key is balancing lead generation with your overall positioning and customer experience.


For example, a boutique needs a different website than a discount retailer. Chasing "leads at any cost" might damage their brand.


Some effective strategies include:

  • SEO to get found for relevant keywords
  • Ad campaigns targeted to different buyer stages
  • Social media contests and giveaways
  • Retargeting visitors with ads
  • Email sequences to nurture leads

But none of these work without a solid website foundation and aligning your messaging, design and content to your ideal customers.

Case Study: Local Home Services Company

I worked with a home services company targeting homeowners in a 20 mile radius. Their old website was generic - it could have been for any company in any industry.


We redesigned the site to focus on local homeowners as the ideal customer:

  • Warm, neighborhood-focused design
  • Content about common problems in the area
  • Geo-targeted pages for each town
  • Customer stories and local reviews

This led to a 2x increase in conversions within 90 days.


Goal #2: Build Your Brand and Reputation

Other businesses prioritize brand building over direct sales.


Law firms, medical practices, agencies, and B2B companies often focus on this. They want to be seen as:

  • Established and reputable
  • Experts in their field
  • Anticipating customer needs

For them, the website is like an expanded business card.


These companies need content that shows thought leadership and authority, such as:

  • Industry trend articles
  • Comprehensive guides and resources
  • Executive bios
  • Case studies
  • Awards and media mentions

The design should also match their brand positioning - clean and modern, warm and friendly, bold and cutting edge, etc.


Example: Boutique Law Firm

A specialized law firm needed to attract bigger clients and referrals from other firms. Their old site was disjointed with no clear brand.


The new website presented them as focused experts:

  • Sleek, on-trend design
  • Client testimonials and successful case results
  • Bios highlighting specific partner skills and awards
  • Library of detailed legal resources

This cemented their reputation and increased attorney fees over 20%.

Goal #3: Share Information and Attract Followers

Some business owners originally started sharing information online just because they were passionate about a topic.


Now, they want to turn that audience into a business - but without losing their followers. Examples include:

  • Bloggers
  • Crafters/makers
  • Photographers
  • Artists and musicians

The priorities here are showcasing their content and personality. Sales come second.


They need:

  • An on-brand look and feel
  • Blog, portfolio or music front and center
  • About section with their story
  • Tools to share content and follow their work

Converting fans into buyers comes later once trust is built. This takes patience and consistently great content.

Example: Quilting Blog

A popular quilter had thousands of blog readers. But she wasn't sure how to turn this into a business.


We designed her site to transition readers into customers:

  • Digital fabrics area to purchase prints
  • Blog split into tutorials, patterns, inspiration sections
  • Shop section with quilt designs and tools
  • Calls-to-action at bottom of blog posts

In the first year her pattern sales doubled - all while retaining her loyal readership.

Goal #4: Promote A Local Service Area

Some businesses only serve customers in a small geographic area. Their priority is promoting their service area and physical location.


Examples include restaurants, boutiques, contractors, photographers, gyms, etc.


Their website needs to:

  • Spotlight their location
  • Have optimized pages targeting each service city
  • Make it easy to call and find their hours
  • Showoff their store or facilities
  • List steps to work with them locally

Getting found on searches for "best __ in San Francisco" is key. Ad campaigns should also be geographically targeted.

Case Study: Local Dance Studio

A family-run dance studio struggled when big chains expanded into their area. Their site didn't highlight why students should choose them.


Their new website focused on their local roots:

  • Teacher and student spotlights
  • Calendar of local events
  • Benefits for area residents
  • Classes split by each suburb

This helped them compete against the bigger brands coming to town.

Goal #5: Launch a Passion Project

Some websites aren't directly for business goals - they're passion projects or causes.


People build these sites to:

  • Promote a cause/nonprofit
  • Share a hobby like genealogy or sports
  • Get discovered like actors, artists, musicians
  • Promote a side project or small business idea

The focus is on getting eyes on the site and building momentum vs revenue.


These websites need:

  • A simple but effective design
  • Clear calls-to-action
  • Social sharing
  • SEO keywords
  • A small marketing budget for ads

Success is getting visitor feedback, social shares, and monitoring growth signals. Proving the concept to eventually turn it into a business.

Example: Volunteering Portal

Someone with a nonprofit background wanted to create a site to match volunteers to opportunities.


The MVP included:

  • Basic listings for events and causes
  • Ability for nonprofits to post needs
  • SEO optimized by geographic area
  • Social campaigns to drive visitors

Focusing on a solid foundation instead of advanced features allowed the site to launch quickly. Site traffic has grown 10% a month since the soft launch.

Summing Up

Why does your website need to exist? Defining this helps align your strategy and priorities.


Of course, over time business goals often evolve. You may start as a passion project and turn it into a lead generation machine.


But starting with focus established the right foundation. You can iteratively improve and optimize to meet shifting needs - without having to rebuild your site from scratch each time.


I hope this gives you insights into common small business goals. Feel free to reach out if you need help getting clarity around your vision and how a website can help make it a reality.